SoR gives almost nothing Defensive/supportive. The same reason why Def banner is in there(tho it could be replaced with Endure Pain). SoR, I feel, is very VERY overhyped thing.
Soldier's Runes are out of reach. The Defensive bonuses(not to mention Rejuvenation!) from Dolyak Runes are too good to pass.
BS gives almost nothing Defensive/Supportive too. The returns from SoR give you much more than BS does for your whole team (Unless you have another warrior with you using BS). Don't even bring up the rez, because if you don't use BS til you have to rez someone then you completely waste the skill. It's pretty much common sense by this point in the game that SoR>BS for all builds except for in 1-2 certain fights, or if you have another Warrior on your team who uses it at the same time as you.
What are you talking about? In a shout build, Runes of the Soldier would give you a minimum of 4 condition removal ever 20 seconds (Could go as high as 20 depending on how many allies you hit that have conditions) and it gives the exact same bonuses as Runes of the Dolyak except the Toughness/Vitality values are switched. Not to mention that you should almost never use runes for straight stat bonuses. The regeneration from 6 runes of Dolyak is only 30 per second. To put that into perspective, the Regeneration Boon gives 130 (With no Healing Power). That means that your runes are less useful than 25% of a single boon.
I also do know what a Wammo is. It's a Warrior/Monk that is pretty easy to use in PvE as it gives you healing, a hard rez, and the benefits of a warrior's defense/damage. The amount of healing/support/damage/everything else this build gives PALES in comparison to a shout build such as Sithicus' and you should really read his threads. This build is Viable but there are much better options when it comes to effectiveness.
Which is totally wrong. I just hope that I didn't revive Tanks with this(we Already got healers and I sincerely hope that we still don't have tanks).
We do have pseudo-tanks and pseudo-healers but this build is neither. Also, the pseudo-tanks/healers are most often hand in hand and are called Support. You can heal and you can take a lot of damage but you can not actually be a tank or a healer in the traditional way.
To say that the ideal is "totally wrong" is incredibly flawed. Many people enjoy being a healer or a tank, to take the option out completely and make everyone a dps would be asinine. They just made them unnecessary, which is a great idea.
To be honest, you didn't revive anything with this build because it's not even as effective as many other builds (No offense). Like I said, this build really pales in comparison to a shout build like Sithicus' and you should definitely read his thread.
Edited by Brand, 27 December 2012 - 04:20 PM.