Find content
Male
Spoiler
To put it simply, the way that the fight with Kralkatorik went in Edge of Destiny does not seem to match up with what Destiny's Edge says during the Personal Story. Here's what I'm seeing:
In Edge of Destiny:
- Eir tells Logan to do what is right, and he leaves.
- After the fight, Zojja turns around and blames Eir's plan for the failure, NOT Logan's leaving (this seems really illogical, and comes out of nowhere).
In GW2 (around level 30, when they try to meet up again):
- Zojja blames Eir's mistake for their failure
- Talking to Eir afterwards, she believe that the failure was her mistake, too
How does that work? Reading the book, everyone should blame Logan (and indeed, everyone on the forum does), but there are differing thoughts on who is to blame for the failure. Zojja seems to think that the plan could have been done better, but Eir didn't do something, and that caused it to fail.
Therefore, I would propose that the following things need to be corrected in Edge of Destiny:
Instead of Eir saying "Do what is right!", she gives Logan the option to leave, proposing an alternate plan to allow him to leave while still having a viable plan. Zojja protests, saying that the second plan won't work, but Logan is already taking to the second plan, believing that they'll be able to handle it without him. He leaves, at least partially believing that they can succeed with the second plan.
It doesn't work, and Zojja blames Eir for the plan, while Rytlock blames Logan for leaving.
Does that seem like a reasonable reconciliation?
In Edge of Destiny:
- Eir tells Logan to do what is right, and he leaves.
- After the fight, Zojja turns around and blames Eir's plan for the failure, NOT Logan's leaving (this seems really illogical, and comes out of nowhere).
In GW2 (around level 30, when they try to meet up again):
- Zojja blames Eir's mistake for their failure
- Talking to Eir afterwards, she believe that the failure was her mistake, too
How does that work? Reading the book, everyone should blame Logan (and indeed, everyone on the forum does), but there are differing thoughts on who is to blame for the failure. Zojja seems to think that the plan could have been done better, but Eir didn't do something, and that caused it to fail.
Therefore, I would propose that the following things need to be corrected in Edge of Destiny:
Instead of Eir saying "Do what is right!", she gives Logan the option to leave, proposing an alternate plan to allow him to leave while still having a viable plan. Zojja protests, saying that the second plan won't work, but Logan is already taking to the second plan, believing that they'll be able to handle it without him. He leaves, at least partially believing that they can succeed with the second plan.
It doesn't work, and Zojja blames Eir for the plan, while Rytlock blames Logan for leaving.
Does that seem like a reasonable reconciliation?
